Selecting a publisher should be a business choice. For many writers, however, this process resembles sleuthing.
A sophisticated website, testimonials from satisfied clients, a Canadian address, and an offer of world-wide distribution may present a publisher as reputable. Yet none of those elements, taken individually, will establish legitimacy of a publishing company. On the other hand, a company asking for payment from the writer for its services cannot be considered a scam per se. The task is to understand the company's business model, the value of the payment, and the writer's fate in all of this.
This is why checking on a publisher may be more difficult than one could imagine.
Why Is It So Hard to Tell Which Publishers Are Legitimate?
There is no single universal checklist in the publishing industry to immediately distinguish between good and bad companies.
An author will come across traditional publishers, independent publishers, self-publishers, assisted publishers, hybrid publishers, and service companies. These companies can operate under totally different business models.
The trouble begins if these business models are deliberately confused.
A company can claim to be a "publishing house" while selling mostly packages for editing, designing, printing, and marketing. Other companies can market themselves as hybrid publishers without disclosing anything about their selection, finances, distribution, and contracts.
The first thing one needs to ask, in this case, is:
What is the actual work of this company, and how does it make money?
What Should an Author Check Before Signing Anything?
Begin by examining the company's identity.
Seek out a real company name, address, contacts, website domain, publishing team, and a history of publishing actual books. Move on to examine what lies outside the company's own website.
For writers in Canada, the Canadian ISBN Publishers' Directory could provide another helpful starting point. According to Library and Archives Canada, this directory contains information on Canadian publishers that have received ISBNs, although it should be noted that both current and defunct publishers are included in this directory and that it cannot be considered an endorsement by itself.
The ISBN itself should also be understood properly. An ISBN is a number assigned to a specific edition of a publication; however, it does not prove that a company is legitimate or offer copyright protection.
This distinction is important because scammers could use legitimate-sounding publishing terminology while failing to deliver legitimate publishing services.
Does a Professional Website Prove a Publisher Is Trustworthy?
No.
It is important to have a professional site, but it is just a start.
Authors need to check the credibility of the statements. Can they find books produced by the company? Can they learn about the publishing process used by the company? Do the company’s charges, products, rights, royalties, revision options, and distribution details clearly explained on the site?
Take special care about promises that are too good to be questioned, like being a bestseller, guaranteed sales, guaranteed media coverage, or guaranteed entry to big publishers.
The correct publishing process can help make a book more presentable and ready for the market. It does not promise that people will buy it.
Are Upfront Publishing Fees Always a Red Flag?
It’s here where many authors begin to get confused.
Not always.
Authors who select either self-publishing or publishing help for a fee might actually have a good reason to be paying for editing, cover design, formatting, printing, marketing set up, or any other services provided.
What matters most is whether the publishing house is being upfront with you.
Writer Beware and the Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers Association advise the authors to check those publishing houses that hide large author fees, use aggressive sales techniques on the writers, make false claims regarding profitability, and won’t give you clear information about costs and contracts.
If the representative offers you the opportunity to sign with him or her via a traditional publishing deal but then all of a sudden demands large sums from the author to acquire rights or get represented, it’s worth checking.
What Does the Publishing Contract Actually Tell You?
More than the sales pitch ever will.
Before signing, an author should understand:
- Who owns the copyright?
- Which rights are being licensed or transferred?
- For how long?
- In which territories?
- How are royalties calculated?
- Who controls the ISBN and publishing accounts?
- What services are included?
- Are additional fees possible?
- Who controls the final files?
- What happens if either party wants to terminate the agreement?
A vague verbal promise is not enough.
For example, an author might be told during a sales call that they will retain complete control and receive worldwide distribution. If the written contract says something substantially different, the contract is what deserves attention.
Canadian publishing organizations also emphasize that understanding copyright, contracts, and rights is an important part of the publishing process.
What If a Publisher Claims to Be Canadian?
Check the claim rather than assuming it.
A Canadian phone number or Canadian mailing address does not automatically establish the nature of a company's operations. Authors should compare the company's stated identity with available business information, publishing records, books it has actually produced, and the details contained in its contract.
For companies presenting themselves as Canadian publishers, professional industry recognition can also provide useful context. The Association of Canadian Publishers' Certified Canadian Publisher program, for example, has specific criteria concerning Canadian ownership, management, publishing activity, and professional operations.
That does not mean every legitimate publisher must belong to a particular association. It simply gives authors another piece of evidence to consider.
What Are the Warning Signs Authors Should Not Ignore?
Be cautious when a company:
- contacts you unexpectedly with an extraordinary publishing offer;
- pressures you to make a fast payment;
- refuses to provide a contract before payment;
- keeps adding unexplained services or fees;
- makes guaranteed sales or bestseller claims;
- is vague about copyright and publishing rights;
- pressures you to purchase large quantities of your own book;
- cannot clearly explain where and how your book will be distributed;
- uses impressive industry names without verifiable connections; or
- becomes evasive when you ask reasonable questions.
One author might be offered "exclusive distribution" and told that another payment is required to activate it. Another might be promised a film adaptation after paying for a promotional package. These offers can sound exciting precisely because they appeal to an author's hopes rather than giving them information they can independently verify.
Writer Beware has documented cases involving impersonated publishers, fake agents, upfront payment demands, and escalating requests for money.
The Safer Way to Evaluate a Publishing Company
Don’t attempt to legitimize based on a single point of awesomeness.
Create an image through multiple facts, like company identity, publishing experience, contracts, rights, prices, ISBN, distribution, independent book availability, author experiences, and communication style.
And then just pose one more question:
Is the real business model of the company consistent with its statements?
This single question may reveal flaws that any fancy website cannot cover.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!
Please log in or create an account to leave a comment on this article. It takes less than 30 seconds!