Yes, selling 5,000 copies is indeed very good for most writers. The majority of books that are traditionally published sell under 3,000 copies throughout their lifetimes, and those that are self-published typically sell even fewer – sometimes hundreds – of copies. Selling 5,000 copies is already an achievement, which exceeds average sales for a debut book and places one above the line between success and failure according to the standards used by the publishers.

However, it should be noted that what is considered "good" may depend on costs involved and royalties. A self-published author who retains 60–70 percent of proceeds from $12 books would earn more than $30,000 from sales of 5,000 books. However, a traditionally published author would earn considerably less, taking into account the advance paid to him/her. This is why authors now tend to evaluate their options through author book publishing services Canada before deciding on how to proceed with publication.